Failure of Soap Extruder Bolt Assembly

Abstract

Present work investigates failure of EN8 steel bolt in a bolt–pin assembly that was used as a fastener in an industrial soap extruder. Unexpectedly, EN19 steel pin that is supposedly the sacrificial element in the assembly remained intact. The investigation follows standard failure-analysis procedure comprising, site-visit, visual inspection, metallography, mechanical-testing, design-analysis, numerical stress-analysis, and fractography. The design-analysis finds that the materials of construction were mistakenly swapped between the pin and the bolt that caused plastic-deformation, necking, and eventual failure of the bolt during operational peak-loading condition. The numerical stress analysis illustrates that the bolts failed at the thread-root region that acted as the stress-raiser. Additionally, the investigation finds that poor-quality machining left-behind jagged thread-root profile that increased the stress-concentration furthermore. The metallography and the fractography indicate that a transverse crack that was initiated at poorly machined thread-root led to the brittle fracture of the bolt. The investigation illustrates how human errors can cause recurring failure of critical components leading to production losses and makes suitable recommendations to prevent such failures in the future. © 2023, ASM International.